The roles of both the mother and father are complete opposites. It is obvious that the bond between Ellen and Mrs. Montgomery is much more stronger. They show both physical and emotional love towards one another. When Ellen finds out her mother is sick she cries as if there is no tomorrow. "With a wild cry she flung her arms round her mother, and hiding her face in her lap..." (p. 23). Mrs. Montgomery also has a deep love for Ellen. "...declaring that she would stay with her (Ellen) and die than take the chance of recovery at such a cost" (p. 24). Mrs. Montgomery is also the one that makes sure Ellen is ready for her trip. She makes sure she has her bible, her sewing kit, writing utensils, and love for God. The relationship between Ellen and her father is completely different. Ellen's father is never there. He is always off working, and when he is home all we hear from him are his feet shuffling up the stairs. When he tells Mrs. Montgomery that Ellen will me leaving the next morning he says it so easily with no emotion. When he sees his upset Mrs. Montgomery is by the news he is more irritated than understandable. "The captain, in happy unconsciousness of his wife's distress, and utter inability to sympathize with it, was soon in a sound sleep, and his heavy breathing was an aggravation of her trouble" (p. 73). He then had no problem stuffing Ellen in the cart with Mrs. Dunscombe's evil maid. Mr. Montgomery was more focused on being apologetic to the maid about being late than saying goodbye to his daughter for the last time. "But Ellen's off-that's one good thing" (p. 77).
I believe Ellen expects two different things from both of her parents. All she wants from her mother is her love and to always be making her happy. "It was real pleasure; she had the greatest satisfaction in seeing that the little her mother could eat was prepared for her in the nicest possible manner" (p. 26). And I don't believe Ellen expects much from her father, since he does not expect much from her.
I must say, I agreed with pretty much everything you said. Mr. Montgomery doesn't seem to care too much for his family. Even witht the little pieces of text towards the end that made it seem as though he had a softer side...I don't buy it. The tiny bit of emotions he should were towards Ellen when he was about to wake her. I think was his "fatherly" love kicking in...and it wasn't enough to change my mind about him. He has no heart for his wife. He showns no knowledge of caring for her feeling OR for the fact that she's dying.
ReplyDelete